“Us vs Them” Has Taken Over American Politics 

It hit me the other day how quickly a normal conversation can turn into a loyalty test. Especially if we’re trying to talk about anything politically motivated.

You say one thing that isn’t perfectly on-script for your “side” and suddenly people are looking at you like you’ve betrayed the whole team. Not because you said something cruel. Not because you lied. Just because you left a little room for nuance. Just because you admitted you’re not 100 percent sure. And in 2026, that tiny bit of uncertainty can get you shamed, piled on, or written off completely.

I think that’s why so many of us feel stuck. We’re not stuck because we don’t have opinions. We’re stuck because we’re scared of what happens if we change our mind, soften our stance, or even ask a genuine question. We’ve built a culture where being curious looks like weakness, and being loud looks like strength. And it’s making us meaner, not smarter.

We’ve both been sitting with the same question: where do we go from here? What do we as a collective society do the next time we’re tempted to type something nasty online? How can we stop trying to prove ourselves and just listen?

One thing we keep noticing is how quickly everything becomes “our side” versus “their side.” A headline drops and people don’t even pause to think. They grab it like a weapon. They post it like a trophy. They use it to prove they’re right and the other side is stupid. We’re tired of it. It’s not making anyone wiser. It’s not making anyone kinder. It’s just making everyone more dug in.

We also talked about labels and how they can help you find your people, but they can also trap you there. “I’m a liberal.” “I’m a conservative.” “I’m a Christian.” “I’m an atheist.” Once you say it out loud, it can start to feel like you’re not allowed to move. Like you’re not allowed to say, “Actually, I’m not sure,” or “I’ve changed my mind,” without getting punished by your own team.

And that’s the part that scares us, because it means curiosity gets squeezed out. If you’re always performing loyalty, you’re not really thinking. You’re just trying not to get kicked out of the group.

We see it constantly on social media. People react to a tiny clip and decide they’ve heard enough. They don’t listen to the full conversation. They don’t ask a question. They just arrive ready to declare what kind of person you are. And then, in real life, it’s completely different. When you’re face-to-face with someone, you remember they’re a person. You see their eyes. You hear their tone. You can’t reduce them to a label as easily.

That contrast has been one of the strangest parts of doing this show. Online, people can be brutal. In person, people are usually softer. Warmer. More open. It makes us wonder how much of this political hatred is real, and how much of it is just what gets rewarded on screens.

We also went into something heavier, the way powerful people keep getting away with bad behavior until they suddenly can’t. The way everyone seems to know what’s going on, but nobody says anything until it becomes useful. And we found ourselves asking the same uncomfortable question: Is that really about protecting people, or is it about protecting the tribe? Protecting the seat? Protecting the story?

We don’t have clean answers. We’re not pretending we’ve solved America in 30 minutes. But we do know this: the “gotcha” culture is rotting our ability to live together. The constant shaming, blaming, and finger-pointing is making everyone defensive and exhausted.

So where do we go from here?

Honestly, we think it starts smaller than people want. It starts with the next comment you almost leave. The next assumption you almost make. The next time you feel that rush of righteousness, and you pause long enough to remember there’s a human being on the other side of the screen.

Ask a question instead of throwing a punch.

And if you can, get to know someone in real life who thinks differently from you. Not as a project. Not to convert them. Just to remember what it feels like to talk to a person instead of a stereotype.

RESOURCES MENTIONED:

Eric Swallwell video:

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DXKWBRbFH76/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link 

Good for the Soul:

The Enemies Project https://www.instagram.com/reel/DXKWBRbFH76/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link

How to find Nicole
How to find Jolene

YouTube

Previous
Previous

Builders not dividers: Voting for character over party

Next
Next

What is a Sanctuary City and how do they work?