Builders not dividers: Voting for character over party

We keep hearing it: don’t talk about politics, religion, or money.

And every time someone says it, I think, that’s exactly why we’re in this mess.

Because the silence doesn’t make the tension go away. It just pushes it underground until it comes out sideways on Facebook, at family dinners, or in the comments section where people act like they’ve never met a human being before.

This week we talked with Stacy Blakeley, the executive director of the Builders Movement, and it felt like we were taking a deep breath. Not because she had some magical “fix America in three steps” plan. But because she kept bringing the conversation back to something we’ve almost forgotten how to do: look for common ground without pretending the differences aren’t real.

Builders is a citizen-first movement built to combat the “us versus them” thinking that’s been sold to us as normal. Stacy called it what it is: the outrage industrial complex. The people who profit off chaos, monetize bad behavior, and keep the rest of us addicted to the drama.

And the most annoying part is… it works.

Outrage gets clicks. Meanness gets rewarded. The loudest voices get the microphone. Meanwhile, the thoughtful majority sits it out, exhausted and convinced nothing will change.

Stacy’s whole point was simple: citizens have to get back in the driver’s seat.

Not as a cute slogan. As a practical strategy.

Because Builders isn’t a think tank. They don’t walk into a room with an agenda and a stack of talking points. They start by listening. Polling. Surveying. Meeting people where they actually live. Then they build guardrails so the conversation doesn’t float off into the universe of “everything is broken.”

They give people facts. They make space for lived experience. And then they do the part most organizations never get to: they help citizens practice.

That’s what Citizen Solutions is.

It’s not a panel. It’s not a debate. It’s not a performative “both sides” photo opportunity.

It’s a carefully selected group of citizens, across race, income, and politics, sitting in a room for three  days and doing the hard work of good conflict.

And yes, Stacy admitted it can be a gamble.

Tennessee was the first big one in 2022, tackling guns in a state where the stakes are high and the emotions are higher. They recorded the whole thing. There’s a documentary called Tennessee 11 that shows what it looks like when a Second Amendment absolutist and a teacher who’s lived through school violence sit down and… don’t destroy each other.

They respected each other. They stayed in touch. Two of the participants in the group are now running for office, one on each side.

That’s not kumbaya. That’s civic muscle.

Then there was Wisconsin.

This one hit me in the gut because it’s so practical it’s almost embarrassing that it took this long: extending postpartum care through Medicaid.

Stacy explained how the issue surfaced. It wasn’t imposed. Citizens raised it. Builders learned Wisconsin was one of only two states left that hadn’t extended postpartum coverage. The room tackled it. The work continued for two years. And in March 2026, those citizens stood behind their governor while the legislation they helped shape was signed into law.

That moment matters.

It proves something we’ve been trained not to believe: the system can move when regular people stay in it long enough.

Stacy said their team had that rare nonprofit moment where you look around and go, “It worked.”

And I loved that she didn’t pretend it was instant. It took patience, hope and persistence.

That’s the part we don’t romanticize enough.

We love the viral clip. We hate the two years of follow-up.

The other thing Stacy kept coming back to was the Builders mindset, built around the four C’s: curiosity, creativity, courage, and compassion.

Curiosity is the one we’ve lost first.

Because when your feed only shows you people who already agree with you, you stop listening. You stop asking questions. You start thinking you know.

And then you get mean.

Stacy said something that matched what we’ve seen over and over: people are nice in person.

Even when they disagree.

The mere proximity changes the whole tone. You can still have a feisty conversation (and you should). But it stays human.

Online, it turns tribal fast. People hide behind fake personas. They throw grenades over their phones. And the algorithm keeps feeding them more reasons to stay angry.

We’ve seen it at the most local level too.

Jolene talked about a planning and zoning referendum in rural Missouri, and how something as unglamorous as zoning turned into vitriol on Facebook. That’s where we are now. We can’t even talk about zoning without someone calling someone else a communist.

So what does Builders do about it?

They shape the narrative with high-quality content that models what civil dialogue actually looks like.

And then they build programs that let people practice it.

Because telling someone to “be civil” is useless if they’ve never seen it done.

Stacy also gave us one of the most honest answers of the conversation when we asked what worries her most.

It’s not “the other side.”

It’s the outsized influence of a small group of people who rig the game before it even starts: donors, parties, lobbying power, and the incentive system that rewards extremes.

Her technical term was perfect: the incentives are jacked.

And she’s right.

Congress has approval ratings that hover in the single digits, yet incumbents keep getting re-elected at absurd rates. We say we hate the circus, then we keep buying tickets.

Which is why Builders is trying to change the incentives from the outside.

In Texas, they ran a turnout campaign that was weird enough to work: “Turnout or Rollover,” featuring an armadillo mascot, billboards, sidewalk chalk, and a masked actor reveal. It wasn’t just funny. It was strategic.

Because the people who reliably show up for primaries are often the most ideologically committed. When turnout is 7–10%, you end up with more extreme candidates, and the cycle repeats.

They targeted the thoughtful majority.

And the group that responded most? 18–24-year-old men.

Of course it was. Weird works.

They also built a Builders Index for Texas primary candidates: builder, toss-up, or divider, based on behavior and bipartisan work. Stacy was clear that it’s not perfect, but the point isn’t to tell you who to vote for. It’s to teach you how to evaluate.

Character. Track record. Integrity. Willingness to work with people.

Basic hiring criteria, honestly.

And yet we don’t apply it to the people controlling billions of dollars and writing the rules we live under.

The part that stuck with me most was when Stacy reminded us: small groups have changed the world.

The Federalist Papers. The lunch counter sit-ins. Women in a salon talking about suffrage before it was respectable.

It always starts small.

And then it scales.

So if you’re sitting there thinking, “Who am I to do anything about this?”

You’re exactly who.

You don’t have to be a politician. You don’t have to be a policy expert. You don’t have to have a perfect opinion.

You just have to be willing to stay human.

To stay curious.

To practice good conflict.

And to stop rewarding the people who refuse to see the humanity in anyone who disagrees with them.

RESOURCES MENTIONED:

Builders Movement: https://buildersmovement.org/

Tennessee 11 Documentary Trailer: https://youtu.be/p-drQKzz2q0?si=ulCjPJeR5xHXtXLl

Bridge Grades: https://www.bridgegrades.org/ 

Builders Texas Primary Campaign- Turn out or rollover: https://youtu.be/va4dmwxtqXE?si=JqNGa5KdokVFV9yh 

Ben Sasse 60 Minutes: https://youtu.be/dDveT8OesWA?si=-gfjZB6j7RHA-kn0 

Political Integrity Substack: https://politicalintegrity.us/ 

Good for the Soul: Raye “Joy”: https://youtu.be/taHYtEGxLnw?si=NpLgzbEJTMapPfMU and the live performance: https://youtu.be/2scS3s_I050?si=bkp9PLF9Mz6AilmR

How to find Nicole
How to find Jolene

YouTube

Previous
Previous

How Postpartum Medicaid Went From 60 Days to a Year in Wisconsin

Next
Next

“Us vs Them” Has Taken Over American Politics