Our Thanksgiving Traditions: How Food and Family Unite Us Across Political Lines

Thanksgiving is supposed to be about gratitude, family, and obscene amounts of food. However, with tensions so high in America right now, we can appreciate that the holidays may be more highly charged than usual. Today, we're talking about how to actually enjoy Thanksgiving without either avoiding all meaningful conversation or ending up in a screaming match over mashed potatoes.

I (Nicole) grew up with Thanksgivings surrounded by friends who became family, home-cooked meals, and the kind of laughter that makes your face hurt. It was warm, chaotic, and filled with people who genuinely enjoyed being together. As an adult, my Thanksgivings have tended to be surrounded more by my “chosen family”, which consists of family and friends. It’s a wonderful time of year to make sure that everyone feels included and has somewhere that they feel welcome.

Jolene's childhood Thanksgivings were mostly at her dad's side of the family, filled with cousins and the kind of fun that only happens when you cram too many people into one house. As an adult, her Thanksgiving got tangled up with college football schedules, creating gatherings with sports teams that added their own lively energy to the holiday. As her children grow up and get married, Thanksgiving will change again to incorporate other traditions from a whole new set of wonderful people.

What's interesting is how our traditions diverged, but the essence stayed the same - togetherness, gratitude, and way too much food. Our families looked different, our menus had regional variations, but the heart of Thanksgiving remained constant: gathering with people you care about and being grateful for what you have.

It can be a little tricky around the holidays, though. Thanksgiving has become synonymous with anxiety about conversations going sideways. Everyone's bracing for the moment someone brings up politics, immigration, or whatever controversy is dominating the news cycle, and suddenly you're not having dinner anymore, you're having a debate where nobody wins and everyone leaves angry.

What Jolene and I have learned over years of friendship across political lines is: curiosity beats judgment every single time. When someone says something you disagree with, your instinct is probably to correct them, argue with them, or mentally write them off as ignorant. But what if you asked a question instead?

Not a gotcha question designed to trap them or prove they're wrong. A genuine question that starts with "how" instead of "why." 

How did you come to that conclusion? 

How does that policy affect you personally? 

How do you think that would work in practice? 

These questions invite conversation instead of confrontation, understanding instead of argument.

The key is remembering that everyone is the protagonist in their own story. You're the main character in your life, and everyone else is a supporting character. But guess what? They feel exactly the same way. They're the hero of their story, operating from their own experiences, values, and understanding of the world. When you approach conversations from that perspective, it's easier to listen without immediately judging.

This doesn't mean you have to agree with everything your relatives say. It doesn't mean you can't have boundaries about what topics are off-limits. It just means approaching disagreement with curiosity about how someone arrived at their position, rather than immediately dismissing them as stupid or brainwashed.

One thing that we can all agree on is that Thanksgiving is all about the food. It doesn’t matter what side of the aisle you sit on, food is the real MVP here. Jolene and I both have our traditional staples like turkey, mashed potatoes, and gravy. But then our regional differences show up. Jolene's family does smoked turkey, which sounds amazing. My family embraced southern dishes like okra and cornbread dressing, which apparently, is controversial in some circles.

The beauty of Thanksgiving is that it forces us to gather with people we might not choose to spend time with otherwise. Extended family, in-laws, that one cousin who always says inappropriate things - they're all there, and you're all stuck together for several hours. You can either make it miserable or make it meaningful.

Jolene and I are proof that people with completely different political views can not only coexist but genuinely enjoy each other's company. The secret isn't agreeing on everything - it's respecting each other enough to listen, ask questions, and assume good faith.

This Thanksgiving, our challenge to you is simple: approach your gathering with an open heart and genuine curiosity. When someone says something you disagree with, ask them a question instead of starting an argument. When you feel yourself getting defensive, take a breath and remember that everyone at that table has their own story, their own struggles, their own reasons for believing what they believe.

Set boundaries if you need to. It's perfectly okay to say "I'd rather not discuss politics today" or "Let's focus on what we're grateful for instead of what we're angry about." You don't have to engage with every provocative statement or rise to every bait.

But also don't avoid all meaningful conversation just because it might be uncomfortable. Some of the best Thanksgiving memories come from real conversations where people share their actual thoughts and feelings, where vulnerability and honesty create connection instead of conflict.

Thanksgiving is about gratitude, and we're genuinely grateful for each other, for our chosen families, and for the space we've created to explore our differences while celebrating our shared values. We're grateful for the people who show up, who try, who choose connection over being right.

So as you gather around your table this Thanksgiving, remember it's not just about the meal - though the meal is important and mac and cheese absolutely belongs on the table. It's about the people, the stories, the moments of connection that happen when we choose curiosity over judgment and understanding over argument.

Happy Thanksgiving from two friends who prove that liberals and conservatives can break bread together without breaking each other.


RESOURCES MENTIONED:

Luby's: 

https://www.lubys.com/

Kerrygold USA: 

https://www.kerrygoldusa.com/

Good for the Soul:

People Choosing Kindness (Instagram): https://www.instagram.com/peoplechoosingkindness/

Tangle: 

https://youtu.be/_ys-UNz5U24?si=sNsUCJ3LVAreVQWN

Links:

How to find Nicole
How to find Jolene

YouTube

Previous
Previous

Working Full-Time But Still Poor: The 55 Million American Households We Need To Talk About

Next
Next

Prayer vs Meditation: Your Brain Can't Tell the Difference