Presidential Pardoning Power

Should the President of the United States hold the power to grant pardons? 

In our latest podcast episode, we tackled this burning question, particularly focusing on the pardons issued by Trump related to the January 6th Storming of the Capitol event. Should such pardons be allowed, and do they hold ethical ground? 

Examining Pardons: Trump vs. Biden

During our discussion, we explored the ramifications of pardons issued by Trump and Biden. Jolene raised an important point about Biden's preemptive pardons aimed at protecting individuals involved in January 6th based on fear of future retaliation from Trump and his constituents. Meanwhile, Trump's broad forgiveness for those who assaulted law enforcement officers during the insurrection strikes as both confusing and deeply concerning. 

Can advocating for "Blue Lives Matter" coexist with pardoning those who threaten them? These actions lead us to question if presidential pardoning power requires oversight or limitations, ensuring it's not wielded unilaterally.


The Ethical Debate

We delved into the ethical considerations surrounding these pardons. While there is constitutional authority for this power, both personal fear and political rivalry appeared to drive recent decisions.

Are such motives ethically justifiable? 

Nicole likened the situation to a competitive, somewhat juvenile stand-off between two leaders, each trying to outdo the other at the expense of national interest. 

Is this the image we want for presidential decision-making?

Additionally, the repercussions of these pardons on our justice system and societal values are complicated and require a lot of deep discussion.


Seeing the Bigger Picture: Media Consumption and Political Perspectives

Understanding both sides of the political aisle is so important in dissecting issues like presidential pardoning. Both of us have started following media from the other side of the aisle, so that we’re aware of what the other side is consuming. This is giving us a broader picture of the political landscape and the biases that exist. Whether you lean left or right, knowledge of the opposing viewpoint strengthens your arguments and fosters informed discussions. We shared several media recommendations that we’ve included in the resources section of this article, encouraging exploration beyond one's echo chambers.

Ultimately, we're striving for a more balanced approach to political discourse, one that rises above tit-for-tat tactics. Whether it's reconsidering the parameters of the presidential pardoning power or engaging with a variety of media, critical and ethical evaluation from all sides can lead to more fruitful, less divided conversations about our nation's future.

RESOURCES MENTIONED:

Tangle: https://www.readtangle.com/

Free Press: https://www.thefp.com/

404 Media: https://www.404media.co/

Status News: https://www.status.news/

LINKS:

How to find Nicole
How to find Jolene

YouTube

Previous
Previous

Debating RFK’s Role as Secretary of HSS

Next
Next

what does it mean to be a liberal or a conservative?