Reaction to the Blue Quake: A Conservative and a Liberal on the Midterm Results

We recorded this episode on November 4th, the day after the midterms. Jolene is conservative, I'm (Nicole) liberal, and we were both surprised by the results.

I have to admit, I ate crow. After a recent snippet we shared on social media, I got a lot of mean comments on Facebook for saying I didn't think there would be a blue tsunami. Part of that was me trying to manage my own expectations, and part of it was that I genuinely didn't see this coming. Nobody did. It wasn't a tsunami. It was a quake, a big blue earthquake that rattled the whole country. I was wrong.

Jolene came in with three takeaways.

One: she's proud of the American people for not voting along party lines. We've spent years putting voters into boxes, and she thinks a lot of people just ignored them this time.

Two: primaries matter. We've been saying it for six months, and she wonders whether a few of these races would have gone differently with different nominees.

Three: what will Trump do now? She's glad he hasn't called the results fraudulent, but the next two months make her nervous. Her read is that he's a deal-maker, and that he'll work with a Democratic Congress and then take the credit.

My message was for Democrats, and I'll be blunt about it. A lot of Republicans and Independents voted for Democrats. I don't think they voted for the party. I think they voted for the better candidate. Tell us what you actually stand for, and make room for the people on the right who crossed over to help you.

And Democrats, please don't gloat. After the 2016 election I was gutted, and the next morning, standing outside my door, I got a call from Jolene checking whether I was okay. She didn't rub it in or lecture me. She just asked. I think about that call a lot, because that's the kind of winning I want from my side.

I'll admit the next bit surprised me. Jolene had Fox News on that morning and caught James Talarico's interview. She was impressed that he said he's all for checks and balances but not for retribution, and that he named things he and Trump might agree on, like housing costs and the federal gas tax. I loved that, too. He sounded like he was thinking, not yelling.

The thing that I can't quite figure out is that not one independent won. Jolene pointed out that in a handful of deeply Republican states, the Democrats seemed to have stepped aside for independents, and all of them lost. I don't know if they split the vote or if people just wanted something different. My guess is it's less that people want Democrats and more that they want something that challenges what's going on.

I also wish I could say the money didn't bother me. I read that almost three billion dollars was spent on the Senate races alone, and a lot of those candidates still lost. Some others won without all that cash. I know it's the kumbaya in me, but imagine if we'd spent all that money on something else. Three billion dollars could have made a real impact elsewhere.

We didn't agree on everything, and I want to be honest about that. Jolene said she hopes we can stop talking about systemic racism now that several Black governors have been elected. I said I think the best people won and they happened to be Black, but I still believe systemic racism exists, and that we have a poverty and class problem we haven't solved. I don't think we landed anywhere, and I'm still thinking about it. But we agreed on this much: celebrate the opportunity, and don't pretend the work is done.

Neither of us knows what the next two years will look like. I think Democrats have to get realistic about who they are, because they can't swing further left and win. I'd love to hold some of these politicians accountable, and there has been so much corruption, but if "lawyer up" turns into political theatre, they'll lose all of us again. Jolene doesn't think they can resist the drama. I'm afraid she's right.

What I keep coming back to is something Jolene said at the end. When she woke up that morning, the election felt like one small piece of her life, not the whole thing. We're still pretty new at this American experiment, and if it doesn't work in two years, we'll try again.

RESOURCES MENTIONED:

Bridge USA post: https://www.instagram.com/p/DfVZVs9n85s/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link&cplk=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==&srtk=MzRlODBiNWFlZA== 

Talarico on Fox: https://www.foxnews.com/media/texas-senate-victor-james-talarico-lays-out-common-ground-trump-vows-work-together 

Citizen McCain podcast: https://www.youtube.com/@CitizenMcCainYouTube 

Bridge Grades: https://www.bridgegrades.org/ 

Problem Solvers Caucus Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/problemsolverscaucus/?hl=en 

MO News: https://www.mo.news/

We’ve Got To Talk - Where To Find Us :

Instagram https://www.instagram.com/wevegottotalk/ 

Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/weve-got-to-talk/id1797423701

Spotify:  https://open.spotify.com/show/0qJVgTvjciUffRmoUienx2

How to find Nicole
How to find Jolene

YouTube

Next
Next

Is Your News Diet All Junk Food? Mo News on Bias, AI & Trust