Monica Guzman: Why Talking Politics With Family Isn't Just Okay - It's Essential

We're told not to talk about politics, religion, or money with friends and family. But what if that advice is exactly what's destroying our ability to function as a country? That's why we invited Monica Guzman - author of "I Never Thought of It That Way," and advisor at Braver Angels to be our very first guest. If anyone knows how to have fearlessly curious conversations in dangerously divided times, it's Monica. And she didn't hold back.

Monica thinks America is fraying. Not just divided - anxious. We're collectively worried about whether this whole experiment can survive the constant barrage of outrage, misinformation, and loneliness. As an immigrant, Monica says she sometimes has more optimism than those who were born here. She sees what's worth preserving, and she believes the only way forward is to keep talking to each other, especially across disagreement. Too many people are looking for the exits, she says, when what we actually need is to stay in the room.

We asked Monica about social media, and her answer was brutal: it's made it easy to be incurious while feeling righteous. Outrage and fear get rewarded with likes and shares. The people profiting off our division are what Monica calls "conflict entrepreneurs". They’re thriving while the rest of us are miserable. But that doesn't mean every conversation is doomed or that social media is inherently evil. It just means that having real, meaningful conversations about contentious topics takes more resilience and skill than ever before.

Monica's advice? Step away from the keyboard. Pick up the phone. Meet for coffee. Have those tough debates face-to-face, where empathy and nuance actually have a fighting chance. Because when you're looking someone in the eye, it's a lot harder to reduce them to a caricature or dismiss their humanity.

With the holidays approaching, we had to ask Monica for advice on navigating family gatherings where political divides run deep. Her first tip: know what you're after. Are you seeking connection, or are you secretly hoping to change someone's mind? Because if it's the latter, you need to understand that persuasion only works if you first genuinely understand the other person. No one's mind changes when they feel judged.

And if your goal is to repair a relationship that's been damaged by political disagreement, be prepared for it to be hard. The other person might not meet you halfway. They might not even acknowledge your effort. But curiosity and grace are contagious, Monica says. Even if you're the only one modeling them, you're planting seeds that might grow later.

One of Monica's most practical pieces of advice is something Jolene and I have discovered ourselves: swap "why" questions for "how" questions. Instead of "Why do you believe that?" try "How did you come to believe that?" The difference seems subtle but it's profound. "Why" puts people on the defensive, making them reach for canned talking points or rehearsed arguments. "How" invites them to share their story, their journey, their actual human experience.

When we share stories, Monica reminds us, there's nothing to contest. You can't argue with someone's lived experience. You can only listen and try to understand. And when you do that, misconceptions start to melt away and you start seeing the person instead of the political position.

Monica shared a story from her own reporting that perfectly illustrates this. After the 2016 election, she organized a trip for a group of liberal Seattleites to visit Sherman County, Oregon - a deeply conservative, agricultural community. The goal wasn't to educate or persuade, but simply to understand. What they found was eye-opening.

The issues that mattered most to the farmers - water rights, land use, agricultural policy- were completely different from what the city dwellers assumed conservatives cared about. And the farmers, for their part, were surprised to meet liberals who weren't out to destroy their way of life but were just, well, people trying to understand a different perspective.

The lesson? We're all terrible at estimating what the "other side" really thinks. Studies show that both liberals and conservatives wildly overestimate how much the other side supports extreme positions like political violence. The real numbers are tiny (we’re talking single digits) but our projections are huge. We imagine the worst about each other and then react to those imagined extremes instead of engaging with real people and their actual beliefs.

The best intervention, Monica says, is simply correcting these misperceptions by talking to real people. Not the loudest voices on Twitter or the most extreme examples on cable news, but actual humans in your community who happen to disagree with you politically.

Some people argue that maybe it's time for America to split up, to become the "Divided States" where liberals and conservatives just go their separate ways. Monica pushes back hard on this idea. The notion that we're hopelessly divided is a lie, she says - one pushed by the extremes for political gain. In reality, most of us want something in the middle. 

The more time we spend only with people who agree with us, the dumber we get. Our blind spots grow, our worldviews narrow, and we lose the ability to make wise decisions for a healthy society. We need each other, Monica insists. We're part of the same beating heart, whether we like it or not.

This hit home for both Jolene and me. Our friendship works because we challenge each other's assumptions, fill in each other's blind spots, and force each other to think beyond our comfortable echo chambers. We're better thinkers, better citizens, and honestly better people because we engage with perspectives different from our own.

So is there hope? Monica thinks so, and after talking to her, we do too. She sees it in the growing number of people on both sides who are tired of the yelling and ready for something different. She sees it in podcasts like ours, in community bridge-building projects, and in the small but mighty coalition of politicians willing to work across the aisle.

The revolution, Monica says, isn't happening in the halls of power. It's happening in living rooms, coffee shops, and yes, podcasts. The people who dare to cross the divide, to have the hard conversations, to choose dialogue over dismissal - they are the counterculture. They are the resistance to a political system that profits from keeping us angry and divided.

This resonates deeply with what Jolene and I are trying to do. We're not politicians or professional mediators. We're just two friends who refuse to let political differences destroy our relationship, and we're inviting others to join us in that refusal. It's not always comfortable, it's not always easy, but it's necessary.

Monica left us with a beautiful concept: "sonder" - the realization that every person you meet has a life as vivid and complex as your own. When we remember that, when we look at each other as potential friends rather than enemies, everything changes. That person who voted differently than you? They have hopes, fears, struggles, and stories just as real and important as yours.

So as you head into your next family dinner, your next online debate, or your next awkward conversation with someone who sees the world completely differently, try a little curiosity. Ask "how" instead of "why." Listen for the story, not the soundbite. Assume good faith instead of malicious intent. And remember that the way we treat each other, the way we engage across our differences, is what will determine whether we can actually function as a country.

Monica's book, "I Never Thought of It That Way," is a must-read for anyone who wants to be part of the solution instead of part of the problem. And if you're reading this, if you've made it this far, you're already on the right path. You're choosing curiosity over certainty, dialogue over dismissal, connection over contempt.

RESOURCES MENTIONED:

Good For The Soul: 

https://valariekaur.com/books/see-no-stranger/ 

Connect with Monica

https://www.moniguzman.com/book

https://braverangels.org/author/moniguzmangmail-com/

How to find Nicole
How to find Jolene

YouTube

Previous
Previous

5 Pet Peeves & 5 Things That Bring Us Joy

Next
Next

Working Full-Time But Still Poor: The 55 Million American Households We Need To Talk About