Bridgers vs. Dividers: The Report Card That Could Change the Midterms

Most of us don’t actually want “our side” to win. We want the country to work. We want less chaos, less theatre, and fewer people getting rich off outrage while nothing gets fixed.

But the way we talk about politics makes that almost impossible. Everything gets flattened into teams, labels, and loyalty tests. Red vs blue. Us vs them. And once you’re in that frame, you stop paying attention to behavior and start defending the jersey.

This week we welcomed Brad Porteus from Bridge Grades back onto the podcast. He created a report card for Congress that doesn’t measure ideology. It measures collaboration. It’s a simple shift, but it’s a big one. Instead of asking “what do they believe,” it asks “how do they govern.”

What hit me most is how much this challenges the way we’re trained to vote. Most people don’t vote based on effectiveness. They vote based on identity, fear, habit, or revenge. And if you’re already deeply loyal to a party, a report card probably won’t change your mind. Brad was pretty realistic about that.

The real opportunity is everyone else. The people who are exhausted, turned off, or so disgusted they’ve stopped participating. There are a lot of Americans who don’t vote in the last election (100 million of them!). It’s not because they’re lazy, but because they don’t see the point. They don’t trust anyone. They feel like it’s all rigged. They don’t want to pick between two options that both feel like a headache.

Bridge Grades is trying to be an on-ramp back in. Not by telling you what to think, but by giving you one more piece of information that isn’t a partisan talking point. A way to look at a name you’ve never heard of and get a quick read on whether they tend to build, or tend to blow things up.

And yes, we also talked about the obvious problem. People can perform. They can “act nicer” when it suits them. They can say the right words during election season and then go right back to the usual nonsense. That’s not a reason to give up, but it is a reason to be smarter about what we reward.

The bigger idea here is cultural. If we want a healthier politics, we have to stop rewarding the worst behavior. We have to stop treating cruelty like strength and collaboration like weakness. We have to stop letting the loudest person in the room define what leadership looks like.

This is not about becoming bland or “meeting in the mushy middle.” You can hold strong beliefs and still work with other humans. You can fight for what you think is right without turning every disagreement into a personal attack. That’s the kind of grown-up energy we’re trying to normalize.

If you’re curious, go look up your lawmakers on Bridge Grades just to get a second lens. Then pay attention to what happens in your own head when you see a grade you didn’t expect. That reaction is kind of the whole story.

Because if we keep voting like it’s a tribal loyalty test, we’re going to keep getting tribal outcomes. And we’re all going to keep sitting here, wondering why nothing works.

RESOURCES MENTIONED:

Bridgegrades.org

Brad's Good for the Soul: 

Owen Cutts Old Music Friday: https://www.instagram.com/owencutts/?hl=en

LINKS:

Instagram https://www.instagram.com/wevegottotalk/ 

Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/weve-got-to-talk/id1797423701

Spotify:  https://open.spotify.com/show/0qJVgTvjciUffRmoUienx2

How to find Nicole
How to find Jolene

YouTube

Next
Next

What If We Replaced Politicians With Regular People Picked by Lottery?